Circular economy for evaluating technologies to eliminate colloidal silica from boiler feedwater in thermoelectric plants
Abstract
In Cuba, it is essential to develop a strategy that leads to a circular economy production model in sectors of the chemical industry, and especially in thermoelectric power plants, where the high consumption of technical water for boiler feedwater impacts production costs without the possibility of reusing this water. The presence of colloidal silica in freshwater represents one of the most critical challenges in steam-cycle thermoelectric plants, due to its capacity to generate scale in boilers and deposits in turbines. The objective of this study is to evaluate, from a circular economy perspective, possible technological alternatives to eliminate colloidal silica from boiler feedwater at the Cienfuegos Thermoelectric Power Plant. This study integrates a circular economy approach to water with a multi-criteria comparative analysis of treatment technologies, demonstrating that ultrafiltration (UF) is the optimal alternative for the removal of colloidal silica prior to demineralization systems. Applying the Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) method, technical, economic, and environmental criteria are evaluated to support the final selection. The proposed solution offers high efficiency, reduced purging, a smaller environmental footprint, and operational stability, aligning with the circularity of water resources and validating the second and third principles of the circular economy, as demonstrated by the Inédit circularity index and Circular Trans indicators. A feasibility study for technology transfer was subsequently conducted.
References
2. MEJÍA, J. I. G. Mantenimiento y optimización energética de una planta. Tesis de Maestría, Universidad de Oviedo. 2019. http://www.vaillant.es/tesisdemaster/JonathanIsrael/mantenimientooptimizacion-energetica-de-una-planta/UNIVERSIDAD/OVIEDO/2019/pdf
3. GÁLVEZ, J. J. O. Cartilla Técnica: Ciclo Hidrólogico. Sociedad Geográfica de Lima. 2012. http://ciclohidrologico.com/index.php/ciclohidrico-hrsg
4. EPRI. Guidelines for Membrane Treatment of Boiler Feedwater. 2012.
5. ARONÉS-CISNEROS, A., LASHERAS-ADOT, M. E., & SANTAMARÍAULECIA, J. M. Resinas de intercambio iónico en cationes y aniones de aguas de lluvia en ecosistemas forestales. FIGEMPA: Investigación Y Desarrollo. 2024, 18(2), 162–171. https://doi.org/10.29166/revfig.v18i2.6160
6. VWTS. (Veolia Water Technologies and Solutions). Manual de tratamiento de aguas industriales. Capítulo 09- Sistemas de membranas. 2025 https://www.watertechnologies.com/handbook/handbook-industrial-water- treatment
7. SUAZO-PÁEZ. Economía Circular en Chile: Alcances, problemas y desafíos en la gestión de la ley REP. – PDF. 2017. https://docplayer.es/94038761Economia-circular-en-chile-alcances-problemas-y-desafios-en-la-gestion-de-la-leyrep.html
8. CERDÁ-TENA, E. Principios y características de la economía circular. Economía circular-espiral: transición hacia un metabolismo económico cerrado. Departamento de Fundamentos del Análisis Económico e ICEI. 2019. Tesis de grado. Universidad Complutense de Madrid.
9. CERDÁ, E & KHALILOVA, A. Economía circular. Economía industrial. 2016, 401(3), 11-20. ISSN 0422-2784. https://dialnet.unirioja.es/ejemplar/447151
10. SAATY, T. L. Fundamento axiomático del proceso analítico jerárquico. Management Science. 1986, 32(7),841-855. Scientific Research and Academic Publisher. https://doi.org/10.1287/mnsc.32.7.841
11. BOGART, S. Diagrama Sankey online para análisis de circularidad del agua. 2025. https://sankeymatic.com/build/
12. WBCSD. Circular Transition Indicators: Guidance for the chemical industry to accelerate the deployment of circular metrics. World Business Council for Sustainable Development. 2024. https://www.wbcsd.org › resources
13. INÉDIT. Autoevalúate con la herramienta de circularidad de Inédit. 2025. https://circular.ineditinnova.com/
14. CASTRO, N.; GONZÁLEZ, E. & GUZMÁN, F. Transferencia tecnológica, la integración ciencia, innovación tecnológica y medio ambiente en la empresa. Ingeniería Industrial. 2014,3(3), 277-288. ISSN 1815-5936. https://www.redalyc.org › pdf
15. MIRANDA-MANDUJANO E., SANDOVAL-YOVAL L., CALVO-BAZAN Y., MOELLER-CHÁVEZ G. E, SARRACINO-MARTÍNEZ O. Evaluación del proceso de coagulación-floculación para el tratamiento de un efluente de la industria textil. JEEOS. 2017,1(3),43-54. https://dialnet.unirioja.es›descarga›artículo
16. SPELLMAN, F. R. The science of water: Concepts and applications (4th ed.). CRC Press. 2021.
17. AWWA. American Water Works Association. Water quality & treatment: A handbook on drinking water (6th ed.) 2019. McGraw-Hill Education.
18. HERNAN, J. & ANDERSON, B. Silica in water supplies and its impact on boilers. ASME Water Technologies. 2020.
19. LIBHABER, M. & OROZCO-JARAMILLO, Á. Water reuse: An international survey. IWA Publishing. 2023.
20. EPRI. Water Chemistry Guidelines for Fossil Plants. Electric Power Research Institute. 2010
21. API. Water Management in the Petroleum Industry. American Petroleum Institute. 2013.
22. ASTM. D1192-19: Standard Guide for Equipment for Water Treatment. 2019
23. WATER ENVIRONMENT FEDERATION. Membrane Processes for Water Reuse. 2016
24. API 939-I7: Evaluation of Hydrocarbon Removal and Ion Exchange Resin Performance. 2017
25. IPIECA. Water Management in the Oil and Gas Industry: A Framework for Sustainability. 2020.
26. UNESCO-WWDR. United Nations World Water Development Report: Valuing Water. 2021.
27. UNESCO-WWDR. United Nations World Water Development Report: Partnerships and Cooperation for Water. 2023
This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial.
![]()












Universidad de Oriente